The first funding session for the Grow and Innovate programs is wrapping up. We'll be sending award notifications on December 15. Therefore, we thought it important to share this update on the process used for determining the Grow and Innovate awards.
Deciding who should receive funding from the three competitive programs – Grow (matching funds to add an FTE), Innovate (develop replicable programs), and Consult (hire a consultant for in-depth work) – requires judgement in (1) assessing compliance with the posted standards for each program and (2) comparing and ranking competing proposals.
With your nominations this summer, we assembled a dedicated six-person independent Review Committee composed of network members and sector experts familiar with our unique network. By including network members in the decision-making process, we ensured that insights from those who have great familiarity with the operations of a state association could help the selection process. This hybrid approach, drawing from trust-based grantmaking and participatory philanthropy, strengthens the initiative and promotes a fair and equitable assessment of applications. (Your wonderful feedback at some of the preview sessions we held earlier this year helped point us in this direction, so thank you!)
Two important items merit your attention. First, we – collectively – owe much gratitude to the six individuals serving on the Review Committee. They are doing so for the good of the network, operating separate from NCN staff to make quality, independent decisions.
Second, we have imposed a strict policy requiring complete recusal if a Review Committee member works for a state association that has submitted a proposal for a competitive program. Thus, not only may they not score the proposal from their employer, but also – to avoid even the appearance of bias or impropriety – they cannot score any of the proposals in that program.
The following illustration provides a step-by-step look at the process for reviewing Grow and Innovate program applications: |